Youngsub Yoon

Why Math Education Matters

“Suppose a belt tightly stretched about the equator of the earth just fits. How long a piece should be inserted so that the belt could encircle the earth at a distance of 1m away at all points?”

The answer to this frequently posed math problem is 6.28 m. It may seem strange that the answer is so small, compared with Earth’s circumference, but the math behind the solution is straightforward. Let the radius of Earth be r meters. Then the belt that fits the equator of the earth will be 2πr meters. To encircle the earth at a consistent distance of 1m away, the belt will have to be 2π(r+1) m. The difference between 2π(r+1) m and 2πr m is 2π m or 6.28 m.

When I decided not to eat non-cage-free chickens, some people told me that my decision would not have a non-negligible effect upon the supply of non-cage-free chickens. I also heard someone saying that she invested in the stock market because the stock prices often rose several percents a week while the interest rate was only several percents a year. She ignored the fact that stock prices often drop several percents a week. She should have compared the interest rate with how much the stock prices rise on average. I have a feeling that these people are among those who, in the above problem, would be likely to imagine that a piece much longer than 6.28 m would need to be inserted into the belt.

I imagine that these people, by the same token, are also likely to think erroneously that power plants do not need to increase their production to counteract the fact that they themselves waste energy, since the amount of energy that they consume is negligible compared to the amount of surplus energy the government prepares to prevent blackouts. I also read that a mayor of a small village in Spain squandered their annual budget to buy the lottery tickets in the hope of paying 1 million euro debt. Perhaps, such a mistake is not uncommon. A Korean thief made the same mistake with the money he had stolen. I am sure that the mayor and the thief would not be able to solve the above math problem.

On Internet, I read a question asking why physicists still operate the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) at CERN, even though there does exist a non-zero possibility that harmful black holes will be formed, no matter how small such a probability may be. I had to answer this question by asking why the questioner takes cars even though it is much more dangerous than the LHC. I am sure that the questioner would not be able to solve the above math problem.

On Internet, I read a comment that a wife had added only 1/3 cup of sugar instead of 1/4 cup as in the recipe because her husband didn’t like things too sweet, and it turned out to be perfect for them. Apparently, she didn’t know that the number 1/3 is bigger than the number 1/4.

Math education matters, because the general public, as well as people in influential positions such as mayors or CEOs, should not make mistakes in cases such as these. I am very sorry that the action of the mayor of the Spanish village resulted in more debt for his village instead of less debt. It is also important that the tax-payers who fund scientific research such as the operation and the construction of LHC understand that their money is used in harmless research. I also feel very angry when lottery number prediction companies rip off poor people by lies such as “Secrets to the lottery number discovered!” or “There are reasons why you have never won even the smallest prize amount in the lottery” or “Don’t throw away your lottery tickets even though they didn’t win.”

Many people, including me, harshly criticize the South Korean math education; mathematics is taught in boring ways, students are expected to memorize unnecessarily many mathematical formulas, and too high math level is expected for the least talented students. According to a survey, about 20% of elementary school students (grade 1-6), about 40% of middle school students (grade 7-9), and about 60% of high school students (grade 10-12) have given up mathematics. This shows the seriousness of the South Korean math education problem. On the other hand, even these least mathematically talented students in Korean standards are able to tell right away that 1/3 is bigger than 1/4, which every cook must know.

A vast majority of people have a misconception about “being good at math.” They think that “being good at math” means “being able to multiply two 2-digit numbers in your head.” But, that means being good at arithmetic, not at math. It doesn’t require multiplication of two 2-digit numbers to figure out that the supply of non-cage free chickens will diminish if you don’t eat them, and to understand that there are no reasons why you have never won even the smallest prize amount in the lottery.

We teach mathematics to our children, not because they will be mathematicians, but because we need to give them a mathematical insight. When people have the knowledge and skills necessary to understand critical issues from a mathematical point of view, they will be able to make better-informed decisions about their social, economic, and technological behaviors and practices.